In Defense of Sarah Palin.

She’s a creationist, anti-science, anti-choice, mother of five who sued the federal government for listing polar bears as an endangered species and doesn’t think climate change is man-made. Her kid is having a kid and is possibly being pushed into a shotgun wedding.

And none of this would matter if she hadn’t committed an unforgivable sin: she said ‘yes’ to the opportunity of a lifetime.

Palin’s life is depressingly normal. There are millions of Americans who are smart and attractive, and who hold the same indefensible ideological positions. There are millions of Americans whose teenagers get pregnant. If you aren’t a Sarah Palin, then you know one, and you probably like her, because her nutty right-wingery doesn’t come up when you’re taking your kids to school, or when you bump into her at Starbucks, or when she brings snacks down to the basement for you and your friends.

She seems likeable and intelligent. And as much as this ‘heartbeat away from the nukes’ meme keeps getting played, it’s entirely possible that she could be a capable commander-in-chief. Not to get too corny, but enough pressure will either break someone, or turn them into a diamond. She could be a diamond. We don’t know.

But what we do know is this: she doesn’t have experience. And unlike Barack Obama, who has been attacked for having very little experience as well, she doesn’t appear to have the greatest judgment. Obama, by running a nearly flawless campaign and surrounding himself with capable people, has shown executive judgment. Palin, who giggled nervously as radio hosts called another Alaskan female legislator a “bitch,” and used her executive powers to get herself into some hot water over family issues has shown poor judgment.

Once again, this wouldn’t normally matter outside of Alaska, because she’s a fairly ordinary politician like dozens of other ordinary politicians.

I write this in defense of Sarah Palin, because the one person who’s shown exceptionally poor judgment, John McCain, isn’t getting banged on the way Palin is.

He met her once and he didn’t have her vetted.

That, right there, should be enough to disqualify John McCain and his advisers from ever being involved in presidential politics. It shows an amazing amount of disregard for the sanctity of the office which he’s attempting to fill. When John McCain appointed Sarah Palin as his running mate, he was in a tough spot. Any of his top options would have made for a stagnant ticket (Romney, Pawlenty) or an unelectable one (Lieberman). So he picked a woman — the wrong woman — for the job.

And now she’s the one paying for it.

Latest posts by Shani (see all)

  • Marci

    Perhaps she’s on the wrong ticket. I’m thinking here… If the democrats (black or white) running for office had a pregnant teen, how the media would play on “that”? And what criticisms would “that” get? Funny, when its the Republicans, teenage prenancy is danced over as “awe… everyone gets pregnant, some earlier than others… at least she chose to keep it…” If her mother wasn’t in the government, wonder if the family’d be sending her off for welfare food stamps and diapers. Curiouser and curiouser.

  • I actually agree here, Shani-O. I think, in many ways, McCain has set her up for a huge fall. And that’s irresponsible and particularly cruel. At this point, I’m not sure that Palin is going to make it until November.

    But, had McCain left her alone in Alaska, allowed her to flourish as a public official, maybe she would have gone on to take Ted Stevens’ seat or enter into national politics through some other avenue. She could have truly become a Republican star.
    And by the time she arrived on the national stage, the current media vetting wouldn’t have been anywhere near as serious or relentless.

    Maybe in 2012 or 2016 she would have been a feasible choice for veep. But, to borrow a line from DMX, (Republicans) pumped her up to watch her get beat. And through no fault of her own – she had no choice but to accept when offered the spot.